Skip to main content

Ormonde Solicitors

Menu

The Cost of Ignoring Basic Employment Law Obligations

The Workplace Relations Commission recently awarded more than €79,000 to a chef who had been subjected to serious workplace exploitation while working in Dundalk. The case involved breaches across several areas of employment law, including minimum wage, working time, rest breaks, annual leave, public holiday entitlements, terms of employment, harassment and constructive dismissal.

While the facts of the case were extreme, the decision is an important reminder for all employers: employment law compliance is not optional, and failures in basic obligations can quickly create significant liability.

For most employers, the lesson is not simply that the conduct in this case was unacceptable. The broader lesson is that employers need proper systems, records, policies and management oversight to ensure employees are being paid correctly, treated fairly and protected from discriminatory or exploitative practices

Employment Law Compliance Starts With the Basics

Many workplace disputes begin with relatively basic issues.

Is the employee being paid correctly?
Are their working hours being recorded?
Are they receiving proper rest breaks?
Are they receiving annual leave and public holiday entitlements?
Have they been given written terms of employment?
Are managers treating employees fairly and consistently?

These are not minor administrative matters. They are core employment obligations.

In this case, the WRC found multiple breaches, including underpayment, excessive working hours, failure to provide rest periods, unpaid annual leave, unpaid Sunday premium and unpaid public holiday entitlements. Awards were also made under equality legislation after the WRC found racial harassment.

For employers, this shows how one poor employment relationship can lead to exposure under several different pieces of legislation at the same time.

Underpayment Can Create Serious Liability

Employers should regularly check that employees are being paid at least the applicable National Minimum Wage and that pay records are accurate.

This is particularly important where employees work variable hours, split shifts, long shifts, overtime, Sunday work or irregular patterns.

A common mistake is focusing only on weekly pay without properly calculating the employee’s actual hourly rate. If the hours worked are not accurately recorded, the employer may struggle to prove compliance.

Employers should ensure that:

  • Working hours are accurately recorded;
  • Payslips are clear and consistent;
  • Deductions are lawful and properly explained;
  • Employees are paid for all hours worked;
  • Sunday premium and public holiday entitlements are addressed;
  • Payroll records are retained and regularly reviewed.

Where pay records are incomplete or unreliable, an employer may be in a very weak position if a complaint is brought.

Excessive Working Hours Are a Compliance Risk

Working time obligations are another area where employers can easily become exposed.

Employees are generally entitled to rest breaks, daily rest periods, weekly rest and limits on average weekly working time. The WRC awarded compensation in this case for excessive working hours and failures relating to daily rest, weekly rest and breaks during shifts.

This matters for employers in sectors where long hours are common, including hospitality, healthcare, transport, construction, retail and professional services.

Even where an employee is willing to work long hours, employers still have obligations. Consent or custom does not remove the need to comply with working time law.

Employers should be able to show:

  • When employees started and finished work;
  • When breaks were taken;
  • Whether weekly hours were monitored;
  • whether rest periods were provided;
  • Whether managers understood working time obligations;
  • Whether staffing levels made lawful working patterns possible.

If the business model depends on employees regularly working excessive hours, that is not just an HR issue. It is a legal and operational risk.

Discriminatory Treatment and Harassment Must Be Taken Seriously

The WRC also made an award for harassment on the grounds of race.

For employers, this is a reminder that equality obligations apply to the day-to-day treatment of employees, not just recruitment, promotion or dismissal decisions.

Employers should have clear policies on dignity at work, bullying, harassment and discrimination. However, having a policy is not enough. Managers need to understand what behaviour is unacceptable, how to respond to complaints and how to prevent inappropriate conduct from becoming part of the workplace culture.

Employers should ensure that:

  • Dignity at work policies are up to date;
  • Employees know how to raise concerns;
  • Complaints are taken seriously;
  • Managers receive training;
  • Inappropriate comments or conduct are addressed early;
  • Migrant workers and vulnerable workers are not isolated or ignored;
  • Language barriers are considered where relevant.

A failure to address discriminatory conduct can lead not only to legal exposure, but also reputational damage and serious harm to workplace trust.

Particular Care Is Needed With Migrant Workers

The case also highlights the vulnerability of migrant workers whose immigration status, work permit or ability to remain in Ireland may be closely tied to their employment. MRCI described workers on employment permits as among the most vulnerable people in the Irish labour market.

Employers who employ migrant workers should be especially careful to ensure that workers understand their rights, their role, their pay, their working hours and who they can speak to if concerns arise.

Good practice includes:

  • Providing clear written terms of employment;
  • Explaining pay and working hours in plain language;
  • Avoiding any pressure around permits, documents or status;
  • Ensuring employees can raise concerns safely;
  • Keeping proper records;
  • Using interpreters or translated materials where appropriate;
  • Treating permit holders no less favourably than other employees.

Employers should never assume that a worker’s lack of familiarity with Irish employment law reduces the employer’s obligations. In fact, where a worker is vulnerable, the need for proper compliance and fair treatment is even greater.

Record-Keeping Is Not Optional

One of the most practical lessons for employers is the importance of records.

If a complaint is brought, the employer may need to prove what hours were worked, what pay was provided, what leave was taken, what breaks were given and what terms were issued.

Good records will not fix unlawful treatment, but poor records can make it much harder to defend a claim.

Employers should keep records relating to:

  • Contracts and written terms;
  • Working hours;
  • Breaks and rest periods;
  • Payroll and payslips;
  • Annual leave;
  • Public holidays;
  • Sunday premium arrangements;
  • Training;
  • Complaints and investigations;
  • Policies issued to employees.

A business may believe it is compliant, but if it cannot prove that compliance, it may still face significant difficulty before the WRC.

Employers Should Audit Before Problems Escalate

The safest time to identify compliance issues is before a complaint is made.

Employers should periodically review their employment practices, particularly in areas such as pay, working time, leave, contracts, equality policies and treatment of vulnerable workers.

An internal review can help identify issues such as:

  • Employees working more hours than recorded;
  • Unpaid preparatory or closing work;
  • Unclear overtime arrangements;
  • Missing contracts or outdated terms;
  • Unpaid Sunday or public holiday entitlements;
  • Inconsistent treatment between employees;
  • Managers applying informal practices that conflict with the law.

These issues are often easier and less costly to fix early than after a complaint has been made.

Key Takeaway for Employers

The WRC decision is a serious reminder that breaches of basic employment obligations can create substantial liability.

For employers, compliance should not depend on crisis management after a dispute arises. It should be built into everyday systems: contracts, payroll, rosters, records, training, policies and management oversight.

The practical lesson is clear.

Pay employees correctly.
Record working time properly.
Provide statutory breaks and leave.
Treat employees with dignity.
Take equality obligations seriously.
Pay particular attention to vulnerable workers.
Keep records that prove compliance.

Employment law breaches rarely exist in isolation. Where one area is ignored, others often follow.

For employers, the best protection is not simply knowing the law. It is having systems in place to make sure the law is followed in practice.

📞 Contact us today for confidential guidance.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Ready to Take
the Next Step?

Book a Call

Schedule a consultation with our team to discuss your legal needs and explore your options with confidence.

We Handle the Details

Trust our experienced solicitors to manage your case with precision and care, keeping you informed at every step.

Achieve Your Desired Outcome

Let us help you secure the best possible result—whether it’s a fair settlement, legal resolution, or peace of mind.

Arrange a Call Back or Send a Query

    We are honoured to share that Ormonde Solicitors & Employment Matters has been named the Business All-Star Labour & Employment Law Practice of the Year 2025 & 2026. This prestigious recognition from the All-Ireland Business Foundation reflects our ongoing commitment to fair workplace practices and expert legal representation, led by the dedication and vision of Sean Ormonde. We are deeply grateful to our loyal clients, dedicated team, and the AIBF for their continued support and trust.