€1,000 Constructive Dismissal Award: How Unresolved Workplace Issues Can Accumulate
A recent Workplace Relations Commission decision provides an important lesson for employers: a constructive dismissal claim does not always arise from one major event.
Sometimes, a series of smaller workplace issues can combine to damage trust and confidence to the point where an employee believes they have no reasonable option but to resign.
A former tutor at a youth fashion academy was awarded €1,000 after the WRC upheld what it described as a “very marginal” constructive dismissal complaint.
Although no single event was sufficient to establish constructive dismissal on its own, the adjudicator found that the cumulative effect of the issues raised was persuasive.
For employers, the case demonstrates why workplace concerns should be addressed early, clearly and consistently before they develop into a wider breakdown in the employment relationship.
Background to the case
The employee worked as a sewing tutor at an organisation providing fashion classes and camps for children and teenagers.
She raised a number of concerns during her employment, including:
- Workplace stress;
- Her terms and conditions;
- Difficult relationships with colleagues;
- Staffing and training standards;
- Alleged health and safety issues involving children attending the classes.
The employee claimed she had repeatedly raised safety concerns with management, including concerns relating to extension leads, the suitability of sewing equipment for smaller children and the availability of appropriately trained staff.
She also described an incident in which a child’s finger was injured by a sewing-machine needle.
The employer disputed the employee’s claims and maintained that it had not been made aware of some of the alleged concerns until later correspondence.
The resignation and pay dispute
The employee initially submitted her resignation in September 2024.
She later agreed to withdraw it following discussions which she understood included an increase in her hourly rate from €15 to €17.
However, the company subsequently wrote to her describing the increase as a suggestion rather than a confirmed agreement.
The employee considered this a breach of trust and informed the employer that she would not be returning to work.
The employer maintained that it had not refused the proposed increase, but that the employee’s grievances first needed to be addressed.
What the WRC found
The adjudicator upheld the employee’s complaint, although the finding of constructive dismissal was described as “very marginal”.
Importantly, the WRC did not find that any single incident was sufficient to justify resignation.
Instead, the adjudicator considered the cumulative effect of the difficulties raised by the employee.
The breakdown in communication surrounding the proposed pay increase was identified as particularly significant. It appeared to have caused a major loss of trust from which the employment relationship did not recover.
The employee was awarded €1,000, approximately equivalent to two months’ pay.
What is constructive dismissal?
Constructive dismissal arises where an employee resigns because of the employer’s conduct.
To succeed, an employee will generally need to establish either that:
- the employer committed a serious breach of the employment contract; or
- the employer acted so unreasonably that the employee could not fairly be expected to remain in employment.
The legal threshold is high. An employee cannot normally succeed simply because the workplace was difficult, stressful or unpleasant.
However, several unresolved issues may collectively become serious enough to support a claim.
Why this case matters for employers
The relatively modest award should not distract from the broader employer lesson.
The case shows how workplace risk can accumulate where concerns are not addressed through a clear and trusted process.
The dispute involved several overlapping issues:
- Health and safety concerns;
- Alleged workplace stress;
- Interpersonal difficulties;
- Uncertainty around contractual terms;
- Unclear communication about pay;
- Loss of trust between employee and management.
Individually, each issue may have been manageable. Together, they contributed to the end of the employment relationship.
Key employer lessons
1. Treat safety concerns seriously and document the response
Where an employee raises a health and safety concern, employers should:
- Acknowledge it promptly;
- Investigate what happened;
- Assess whether any immediate action is required;
- Record the findings and response;
- Communicate the outcome to the employee.
This does not mean every allegation must be accepted. It means each concern should receive a structured and documented response.
Where children, vulnerable people or workplace machinery are involved, the importance of clear safety procedures is even greater.
2. Do not allow grievances to remain informal indefinitely
Workplace complaints frequently begin as conversations with a manager.
If the issue is not resolved, the employee should be directed towards a clear grievance process.
Employers should avoid situations where:
- Management believes no formal complaint was made;
- The employee believes concerns were repeatedly ignored;
- Neither side has a written record of what was discussed.
A short written acknowledgement and follow-up meeting can prevent significant disagreement later.
3. Confirm pay arrangements in writing
The apparent misunderstanding over the proposed hourly rate was central to the breakdown in trust.
Any change to pay should be confirmed in writing and should clearly state:
- The new rate;
- The date it takes effect;
- Whether any conditions apply;
- Whether the arrangement is temporary or permanent.
Words such as “proposal”, “suggestion”, “agreement” and “approval” should not be used interchangeably.
An employee should not be left believing a pay increase has been agreed when management considers it subject to further discussion.
4. Consider the cumulative effect of management decisions
Employers often assess complaints separately.
One issue may involve pay, another may involve a colleague, and another may involve safety. Each manager may see only one part of the situation.
The WRC may consider the overall pattern.
Employers should therefore step back and ask whether repeated unresolved issues are contributing to a wider breakdown in trust and confidence.
5. Respond carefully when an employee resigns
A resignation made during a workplace dispute should not always be accepted immediately without further engagement.
Depending on the circumstances, the employer may consider:
- Acknowledging the resignation;
- Asking whether the employee wishes to discuss the issues;
- Clarifying any misunderstanding;
- Allowing a short cooling-off period;
- Addressing outstanding grievances;
- Confirming the final position in writing.
An employer is not always required to persuade an employee to remain. However, a measured response may prevent an avoidable constructive dismissal claim.
6. Workplace culture problems can become legal problems
High staff turnover, unclear responsibilities, inadequate training and strained communication may initially appear to be operational issues.
Left unmanaged, they can contribute to:
- Grievances;
- Absence;
- Resignations;
- Health and safety complaints;
- Constructive dismissal claims.
Early intervention is usually less costly than defending a claim after the relationship has broken down.
Practical steps for employers
Employers can reduce constructive dismissal risk by:
- Maintaining clear grievance and health and safety procedures;
- Training managers to recognise and escalate employee concerns;
- Recording complaints and management responses;
- Confirming contractual and pay changes in writing;
- Reviewing recurring complaints collectively rather than in isolation;
- Addressing workplace relationship difficulties early;
- Obtaining advice when an employee resigns during an unresolved dispute.
The wider message for employers
This decision demonstrates that constructive dismissal is not always based on a dramatic final incident.
A series of misunderstandings, unresolved concerns and unclear management communications can gradually undermine the employment relationship.
The strongest protection for employers is not simply having policies in place. It is showing that those policies were actually used, concerns were taken seriously and agreements were communicated clearly.
How Ormonde Solicitors can help
Ormonde Solicitors advises employers on:
- Constructive dismissal risk;
- Employee grievances;
- Workplace health and safety concerns;
- Pay and contractual disputes;
- Workplace investigations;
- Disciplinary procedures;
- WRC claims and representation.
Addressing workplace concerns early can protect trust, support management and reduce the likelihood of disputes escalating.
📞 Contact us today for confidential guidance.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Ready to Take
the Next Step?
Book a Call
Schedule a consultation with our team to discuss your legal needs and explore your options with confidence.
We Handle the Details
Trust our experienced solicitors to manage your case with precision and care, keeping you informed at every step.
Achieve Your Desired Outcome
Let us help you secure the best possible result—whether it’s a fair settlement, legal resolution, or peace of mind.
Arrange a Call Back or Send a Query
We are honoured to share that Ormonde Solicitors & Employment Matters has been named the Business All-Star Labour & Employment Law Practice of the Year 2025 & 2026. This prestigious recognition from the All-Ireland Business Foundation reflects our ongoing commitment to fair workplace practices and expert legal representation, led by the dedication and vision of Sean Ormonde. We are deeply grateful to our loyal clients, dedicated team, and the AIBF for their continued support and trust.
